In Africa, Botswana trails only Equatorial Guinea in terms of GDP per capita. But considering the despotic leadership in Equatorial Guinea and how few of its citizens have benefited from the nation's oil riches, the average Botswanan is much better off. Unfortunately, that thought doesn't necessarily apply to its Bushmen, whom the country is struggling to help.
When Botswana's High Court ruled three years ago that the country’s Bushmen (also known as the San) should be allowed to live and hunt in their ancestral territories in the Central Kalahari Game Reserve (CKGR), it seemed a comprehensive victory for some of the world's last desert hunter-gatherers. But since then the authorities have issued no licences. In fact, none has been given out since 2001. And a recent court case does not inspire much hope for the Bushmen.
Relocated in the 1990s and earlier this decade, only a few Bushmen have been able to return to the empty scrubland of the central Kalahari since the 2006 ruling. Scores have been arrested for hunting without permits, according to Survival International, a charity that helps indigenous peoples trying to preserve their traditional way of life. This week, for the first time, six Bushmen, including at least one of the plaintiffs in the 2006 case, Tshetha Ntwatamogala, were convicted of illegally hunting gemsbok and eland in the reserve.
At 23,600 square miles, CKGR is about the size of West Virginia...which is a tenth the size of Botswana. When Botswana was still a British protectorate, CKGR was created as homeland for the roughly 5,000 Bushmen them. Decades later, Botswana forced them off of the land. Were the Botswanans reacting against what could be viewed as apartheid or doing something worse to people of a different ethnic group? And what about other factors, like for instance diamond mining.
In the early 1980s, diamonds were discovered in the reserve. Soon after, government ministers went into the reserve to tell the Bushmen living there that they would have to leave because of the diamond finds.
In three big clearances, in 1997, 2002 and 2005, virtually all the Bushmen were forced out. Their homes were dismantled, their school and health post were closed, their water supply was destroyed and the people were
threatened and trucked away.
They now live in resettlement camps outside the reserve. Rarely able to hunt, and arrested and beaten when they do, they are dependent on government handouts. They are now gripped by alcoholism, boredom, depression, and illnesses such as TB and HIV/AIDS.
Despite this, the glittering exports aren't considered blood or conflict diamonds.
Diamonds have been the biggest engine of Botwanan economic growth--the fastest in the world since it gained independence in 1966. The mining of diamonds, copper, nickel, etc. is responsible for 38 percent of the nation's GDP.
But, let's not forget that conservation via social engineering has also played a major role in the Bushmen's situation.
Resettlement in the name of wildlife conservation and tourism promotion has been advocated by a number of African governments and environmental non-government organizations. Such resettlement has major human rights implications, especially in terms of reducing the standards of living and access to land of people are relocated. In May 1997, the government of Botswana chose to resettle several hundred residents outside of the Central Kalahari Game Reserve, the third largest game reserve in Africa. This resettlement, which had been planned since 1986, is having major effects on the people not only in the Central Kalahari but also those in the area where people have been resettled.
...
In the late 1980s and early 1990s the Botswana government had pursued a policy of "freezing" development in the Central Kalahari Game Reserve. When the borehole at !Xade, the largest community in the reserve, broke down, it took months before it was fixed. Buildings and roads were not
maintained in the reserve except for those going to Department of Wildlife and National Parks camps. Even drought relief feeding programs were slower in the central Kalahari than elsewhere in Botswana, a situation which threatened the well-being of people in several parts of the reserve.
Pressures were also brought to bear on people in the central Kalahari through selective enforcement of wildlife laws and what some local people perceived to be intimidation. Data collected on households in the central Kalahari and adjacent areas reveal that up to two thirds of the resident
adult males of some communities have been arrested at one time or another by game scouts from the Department of Wildlife and National Parks, police officers, or Botswana Defense Force (BDF) personnel. One of the impacts of high rates of arrest was that there was withdrawal of much-needed labor from households and communities. This was especially problematic if the person arrested and jailed was a bread-winner or a hunter.
Squeeze the people until most of them leave "voluntarily," and then employ a few of them in community based natural resource management. Tourism supplies another 12 percent of Botswana's GDP. From the Reserve's website...
Safari lodges based in various parts of the Kalahari often hire people of Bushman origin to guide visitors into the desert and to impart their wisdom of how to survive. Often dressed in traditional animal skins and carrying a bow and arrow, they show you how to find water-filled tubers in the sand and explain how to catch an ostrich--which is no easy task! Bushmen are great storytellers and like nothing better than to embellish a tale with elaborate and hilarious demonstrations, accompanied by their fast and furious clicking language. At the end of the day they take off their working clothes--in this case animal skins--and go back to their village. The romantic dream that Bushmen might still be able live as they once did is not a reality, and even the CKGR is no longer theirs as diamond mining companies are taking over what was once Bushman land.
The Bushmen are supposed to be satisfied with a few jobs serving and entertaining the affluent folks visiting, studying, and filming their former homeland. About the only reason they'll be passing along tracking knowledge to their children is so that they can poach.
Human rights groups tend to avoid mentioning the role of conservation in this issue, as they tend to raise money and seek political support in the same circles as environmentalists. Returning to the original article...
As one of the judges in the 2006 case put it, letting people back into the reserve without letting them hunt is "tantamount to condemning the remaining residents of the CKGR to death by starvation".
The government has long argued that hunting in the reserve must remain illegal to protect the wildlife, even though the Bushmen, who hunt with spears, bows and arrows, have a relatively small effect on the animals. Clifford Maribe, spokesman for Botswana’s foreign ministry, says that the authorities are acting in the Bushmen's own interests, pointing out that permanent structures such as clinics and schools cannot be built inside the reserve. "Living inside the game reserve limits their livelihood opportunities," he says. "Their standard of living cannot be improved."
However, facilities in support of diamond mining can be built within the Reserve.
Recent Comments